4 weeks ago
16
Social media exploded excitedly erstwhile Subway announced they were releasing footlong versions of their beloved cookies successful 2023. Lines formed astatine locations fortunate capable to connection these monolithic treats, and customers couldn’t hold to stock photos of themselves holding cookies astir arsenic agelong arsenic their forearms.
This station contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I gain from qualifying purchases.
What makes this specified a amusive cookie?
I had to spot what each the fuss was about, truthful I waited successful enactment for 20 minutes astatine my section Subway to get my hands connected one. The archetypal wound revealed thing astonishing – this wasn’t conscionable a scaled-up mentation of their regular cookies. The texture was lighter, astir cake-like, with crisp edges giving mode to a tender center. The equilibrium of sweetness and cocoa was perfect, and I instantly knew I needed to recreate this astatine home.
After respective trial batches (and galore blessed taste-testers), I’ve cracked the code. The secret? It’s each astir baking these giants successful loaf pans alternatively than connected cooky sheets. This method creates that unsocial texture that makes Subway’s footlong cookies truthful peculiar – and present you tin bask them anytime without waiting successful line!
Why you’ll emotion this recipe
- No peculiar baking skills required – conscionable travel the elemental directions!
- Creates the nonstop light, cake-like texture that distinguishes Subway’s footlong cookies
- Perfect for birthdays, parties, oregon anytime you privation to impress
- More affordable than buying them astatine Subway ($5-6 each vs. astir $1.50 successful ingredients)
- Customizable with antithetic mix-ins to suit your taste
- Makes a amusive enactment for kids who emotion to assistance successful the kitchen
The Secret to Perfect Texture
Their unsocial texture makes Subway’s footlong cookies antithetic from regular cocoa spot cookies. Regular cookies dispersed retired connected a baking sheet, creating bladed treats with chewy oregon crispy textures. But footlong cookies are baked successful loaf pans, which:
- Prevents them from spreading excessively much
- Creates a much cake-like interior texture
- Develops crisp edges portion keeping the halfway soft
- Ensures adjacent baking from borderline to center
The loaf cookware is non-negotiable for this look – without it, you’ll extremity up with regular cookies, not the peculiar footlong experience!
Equipment Needed
- Two 4.5 x 12-inch non-stick loaf pans (Wilton makes an perfect size)
- Parchment paper
- Stand mixer with paddle attachment (or manus mixer)
- Mixing bowls
- Measuring cups and spoons
- Wire cooling rack
Ingredients and Their Purpose
- Unsalted butter – Creates a affluent basal and helps make that tender crumb; utilizing unsalted lets you power the brackish level
- White granulated sugar – Provides sweetness and helps make those somewhat crispy edges
- Light brownish sugar – Adds moisture, extent of flavor, and that subtle caramel note
- Egg – Binds the ingredients unneurotic and adds operation to the cookie
- Vanilla extract – Enhances each the flavors and provides that classical cooky aroma
- All-purpose flour – The operation of the cookie; the circumstantial magnitude is important for the cake-like texture
- Baking soda – The leavening cause that gives the cookies their emergence and airy texture
- Salt – Balances the sweetness and enhances the cocoa flavor
- Chocolate chips – The prima mix-in, providing pockets of melty cocoa throughout
Although it is not an ingredient, the astir indispensable happening successful this look is the close pan. You won’t get the close texture if you cook these cookies connected a expanse pan. You request 2 non-stick loaf pans that are astir 4.5 inches wide and 12 inches long. Wilton makes a great option.
How to marque a Subway Footlong Cookie
To hole the dough:
- In the vessel of a basal mixer, usage a paddle attachment to pick unneurotic the unsalted butter, achromatic granulated sugar, and airy brownish sweetener connected MEDIUM speed.
- Once the food lightens successful colour and becomes fluffy, adhd the ovum and vanilla extract. Mix for 15 to 20 seconds connected LOW. Don’t overmix, oregon the cooky volition beryllium excessively crunchy.
- Whisk unneurotic the AP flour, baking soda, and salt. Add the adust ingredients successful 2 additions to the bedewed ingredients and premix until the dough comes unneurotic but isn’t excessively stiff.
- Add the cocoa chips and disturbance them into the dough with a woody spoon oregon your hands.
To cook the cookies:
- Preheat the oven to 350°F.
- Line 2 loaf pans with parchment paper.
- Divide the cooky dough successful fractional and adhd each fractional to 1 prepared loaf pan.
- Bake connected the mediate rack of the oven for 25 to 30 minutes. Rotate the pans halfway done cooking.
- Place the loaf pans connected a ligament rack to cool. You request to permission the cookies successful the pans portion they are cool to forestall the cookies from spreading.
- Once the cookies are astatine country temperature, usage the parchment insubstantial to mildly assistance the cookies retired of the pans and onto a cooling rack.
Subway Chocolate Chip Footlong Cookie
Ingredients
- 2/3 cup butter
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar
- 1/2 cup brown sugar
- 1 large egg
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 salt
- 1 cup chocolate chips
Instructions
- Preheat the oven to 350°F.
- Using an electrical mixer, pick unneurotic the butter, granulated sugar, and brownish sweetener until airy and fluffy. Add the egg, vanilla extract, flour, baking soda, and brackish and premix until combined. Fold successful the cocoa chips.
- Divide the dough successful half. Place each portion of dough into an ungreased agelong loaf cookware (about 12 x 4.5 inches) that has been lined with parchment paper.
- Place the pans successful the oven and cook for 20 to 25 minutes. Remove from the oven and permission the cookies successful the cookware until they set. If you region the cookies earlier they set, they volition spread.
Nutrition
Recipe variations
It’s casual to swap retired oregon adhd ingredients to alteration up Subway cocoa spot cookies to your liking. Here are immoderate ideas:
- Swap the semisweet cocoa chips with achromatic cocoa chips, beverage cocoa chips, oregon acheronian cocoa chips.
- Add 1/2 cupful of pecans, walnuts, oregon macadamia nuts.
- Substitute cocoa chips with dried berries specified arsenic cranberries oregon blueberries.
What to service with Subway Footlong Cookies
A solid of acold beverage oregon a steaming mug of java oregon beverage is each you request to bask a Footlong Chocolate Chip Cookie, but if you privation to marque these cookies other special, effort pairing them with 1 of these options:
French Vanilla Ice Cream. A Footlong Chocolate Chip Cookie Ice Cream Sandwich? Yes, please! Although determination is nary crushed wherefore you can’t marque them utilizing store-bought crystal cream, homemade French Vanilla Ice Cream volition marque the crystal pick sandwiches truthful overmuch better. You’ll request an crystal pick shaper to hole this custard-based crystal cream; a decent machine isn’t excessively expensive.
Spiced Pecans. If you don’t enactment nuts successful the cocoa spot cookies, you tin ever service them connected the side. But these Spiced Pecans aren’t similar immoderate you’ve ever had before. After a airy dusting of cinnamon and sugar, they are tossed with lukewarm baking spices that springiness them a uniquely delicious taste. These salty and saccharine pecans brace perfectly with the richness of a Subway Footlong Cookie.
Cool Whip Fruit Dip. This creamy dip isn’t conscionable for fruit. Cut cooled Chocolate Chip Footlong Cookies into strips and service them with this casual Cool Whip Fruit Dip. The tang from the sour pick helps equilibrium retired the sweetness of the cocoa spot cookies.
How to store a footlong cocoa spot cookie
You tin support the cookies successful an airtight instrumentality connected the counter, successful the fridge, oregon adjacent successful the freezer! Let the cookies travel up to country somesthesia earlier eating.
How agelong volition a footlong cocoa spot cooky last?
In an airtight instrumentality connected the counter, the cooky volition past a time oregon two. You’ll get an other time of retention if you enactment them successful the fridge, and Subway’s Footlong Cookie volition enactment bully for a period oregon much successful the freezer.
More Subway copycat recipes
Favorite copycat cooky recipes
- Crumbl Chocolate Chip Cookies
- Crumbl Birthday Cake Cookies
- Crumbl Sugar Cookies
- Crumbl Ultimate Peanut Butter Cookies
- Girl Scout Lemonades
- Girl Scout Samoas
- Girl Scout Tagalongs
- Girl Scout Thin Mints
- Panera Kitchen Sink Cookies
- Panera Lemon Drop Cookies
- Walkers Shortbread Cookies
Check retired my easy recipes for cookies and the champion copycat accelerated nutrient recipes connected CopyKat!
Recreate Subway’s viral sensation astatine location with this foolproof copycat recipe. This giant, cake-like cocoa spot cookies seizure the unsocial texture and spirit that made Subway’s footlong cookies an net phenomenon. The concealed is baking them successful loaf pans alternatively than connected cooky sheets, creating that cleanable equilibrium of crisp edges and brushed centers. Costing conscionable $1.50 successful ingredients compared to $5-6 astatine Subway, these awesome treats are cleanable for celebrations oregon whenever your cooky craving strikes. Customize with antithetic mix-ins, alteration into crystal pick sandwiches, oregon service arsenic a day cooky barroom – the possibilities are endless!
English (US) ·